iPhone 4: Incase Slider or Microshell?

as normal (and careful) user of iphone 4, can count how many times drop phone on 1.5 hands (sorta) , of time it's because dangerously balance on clothes when shower , forget it's there , bloop drops (i have iskin solo it's pretty set on impact factor)

anyway let me cut chase: it's time new case.
after spending hours , hours slaving on bright screen through wee hours of morning, have come conclusion of these 2 cases:
marware microshell case
, incase slider case

, i'm stumped.
microshell in has slight lay-on-table design still maintains sense of thinness (most thin shell cases don't have lip)

gripes (which pales in magnitude compared pros) volume/silent cutout, i'm not sure whether can flick finger across switch or not (no biggie though)
, i'm not sure if survive single drop on hard surface (again don't drop phone on regular, , if drop it, chances carpet or if i'm unlucky, hard surface). i'm not worried drop factor , guess it's have sacrifice thin case


incase slider, seems on moderately thin side (by no means pinlo bladedge though, or 1 of heavy-duty otterbox things) , reviews access controls breeze, i'm not fond of 2-pieceness, because lose bottom part i'd without doubt if thinner. hate case , have settle case thick iskin solo (unless can otherwise)

so, compare 2 in terms of cons:
microshell: iphone die single drop i'm more of careful user it's not big issue
slider: 2-pieceness (not big deal), not sure if bodes shock absorption (due it's hardness)

feel free include own opinions , experiences!
i'm leaning towards microshell though..

so, macrumors, me. microshell, or incase slider?

 

i can speak incase slider have yet use mine since i'm big panzy , have have screen protector on. problem hard use screen protector because bubbles up. have cut screen protector , still bubbled up. me thas going issue.

otherwise, slider case big cut outs , smooth shape. have read situations since tight fitting case has cracked rear glass. me love/hate case.

 

Forums iPhone, iPad, and iPod Touch iPhone iPhone Accessories

• iPhone
• Mac OS & System Software
• iPad
• Apple Watch
• Notebooks
• iTunes
• Apple ID
• iCloud
• Desktop Computers
• Apple Music
• Professional Applications
• iPod
• iWork
• Apple TV
• iLife
• Wireless